Is Murray Done?

Yeah, he's our only chance to compete, now. BUT:

Since Ridder is gone, that leaves Tune alone as a backup.
He might do OK with more game experience, or not. But we
have been in trouble before when our #1 QB went down and
#2 followed shortly thereafter. We don't seem to learn
that a GOOD alternate QB or two can be season savers.

Picking up someone 'off the street' just doesn't work.
We proved that with Lindley (sp). Remember that? Or
more recently with Dobbs. Bless them both for trying
in a difficult situation...

IMHO

I thought Dobbs did good under the circumstances and would have continued to improve with more time under less urgent circumstances. I wouldn't even mind if they brought him back in a back up role. The veteran QB I was hoping the Cards had brought in as a back up before Ridder was Tyrod Taylor.

Nope not right time for something that drastic.

I liked Dobbs, too. He did best when winging it immediately after he arrived, and BEFORE he studied the playbook.
And IIRC he did the same after going to the Vikings. That tells me that he is a great improvisor with good instincts, but when he is given scripted plays it kills his natural responses to in-game situations. He has the ability built in, but so far no OC has tapped/adapted to it.

And I like that commercial on TV. A little extra money won't ruin him, and could open more doors besides aerospace.

We are debating amongst ourselves about Murray's capacity to lead the Arizona Cardinals to victories. I have doubts about his physical and mental consistency to lead. Last night's FG for a win did not move me to reconsider Murray's team leadership. Murray was 14/26 for 145 yards, 1 TD, and 1 INT. Passes avg'd 5.6 yds. QBR 78.5. Those are not bragging numbers.

Let's put winning aside and consider another leadership issue. Is Murray a problem for Harrison? Do they communicate when not forced to do so? A week ago, after the GB debacle, Murray said their comms was fixed. I would argue that these two men might not like each other. A person might conclude that Murray is ruining Harrison.

Another question: who is Harrison's foxhole buddy on the team? This would be someone Harrison would trust with his life. Someone he can open up with. A tough GF is an option. I want to put those questions on the table for members to consider. Harrison needs head therapy.

Many physically gifted rookie WRs have struggled through NFL year one. Some WRs did not survive the mental pressures and had to move on. If Harrison was on another NFL team, one with a balanced offense that is a scoring machine, would Harrison still drop easy passes and not be re-targeted after repeated failures? Nobody is coddled in the NFL.